Are the Chiefs Prioritizing Loyalty Over Logic? The Nnadi Nightmare Is a Fireable Offense
Let’s not dance around it. Let’s not make excuses. The Kansas City Chiefs, a team that was on the cusp of a historic three-peat just last season before falling to the Eagles, are currently 2-3. While the panic button is being polished in basements across Chiefs Kingdom, the root of the problem might be staring us right in the face from the trenches. And it’s a problem of the front office’s own making.
I’m talking about the curious case of Derrick Nnadi.
You see, while you were firing up the grill for your tailgate, the analytics nerds over at Pro Football Focus were grading every snap. And they’ve handed down a verdict on Nnadi that should send a shockwave through the organization. According to a thread blowing up on the Chiefs subreddit, PFF has graded Derrick Nnadi as the 186th-best interior defensive lineman in the NFL.
Let me repeat that. Not 18th. Not 86th. ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY-SIXTH. Out of how many, you ask? He’s literally ranked as the WORST in the league among qualifiers.
Now, here’s the kicker. Here’s the part that should make you spit out your coffee. The man they cut to keep Nnadi? Mike Pennel. And where does PFF have him ranked? A respectable 71st.
ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!
Analytics Say It’s a Disaster, But Veach Says “Trust Us”
So how does a front office, led by the celebrated Brett Veach, justify keeping the league’s worst-graded tackle over a proven, solid contributor? Well, according to a fantastic piece over at SportsOrca that breaks down the whole debacle, the Chiefs’ brass is leaning on some classic, old-school football excuses.
Veach’s reasoning boils down to three things: age, durability, and competition. Nnadi is five years younger. He’s barely missed a game. They believe in him. “We would always be open to that for sure. Mike is a special human being, and we love Mike,” Veach said, leaving the door open for a Pennel return that now seems impossible since he’s making plays for the Bengals.
Let me translate that for you: “We like our guy more than the other guy, even if the numbers scream that we’re making a colossal mistake.”
This isn’t about “trust.” This is about ego. This is a front office ignoring the blinking red lights on the dashboard because they drafted Nnadi, they developed him, and they’ll be damned if the stat sheet tells them they were wrong.
This Isn’t Just a Numbers Game; It’s Losing Us Football Games
Don’t get it twisted. This isn’t just about a PFF grade. This shows up on the tape. It shows up on critical third-and-2 situations when the defense gets gashed up the middle. It shows up when opposing quarterbacks have all day to step up in a clean pocket because the interior rush is non-existent.
For a team that’s already sitting at 2-3, every single roster spot is critical. Every snap matters. The Chiefs don’t have the luxury of carrying passengers, especially not on the defensive line next to Chris Jones. You can’t pay Jones $95 million and then line him up next to a guy who is getting consistently manhandled. It’s football malpractice!
The margin for error in the AFC is razor-thin. We saw that last season. The dynasty is not a birthright; it has to be earned every single week. And right now, the Chiefs are willingly choosing to field a player that the entire league knows is a liability.
This isn’t just a questionable move. It’s an arrogant one. It’s a decision that tells the fans that the front office knows better than the evidence. Well, the evidence is a 2-3 record and a defensive line that is getting pushed around. The time for excuses is over. The time for results is now, and this Nnadi experiment needs to end before it sinks the entire season.
Meta Description: Are the Chiefs valuing loyalty over winning? A deep dive into Derrick Nnadi’s abysmal PFF ranking and the front office’s questionable decision to keep him over Mike Pennel, costing the team crucial games.
I have reviewed and revised the article. However, I am unable to post the article to the WordPress API as the provided tools, `default_api.wordpress_api_docs()`, only offer documentation and do not include functionality to create or publish posts.
About the Author
